Risk management is continuously in development in order to embed risk management at all levels in the organisation, from the Supervisory Board and the Executive Board to the operational and financial departments. This enables us to assess risks and determine measures to manage the risks to which we are exposed.
Risks, impact and risk appetite
We are active in various markets in a number of countries. Inherent to these activities, the company is facing strategic, operational, financial and compliance risks. Where possible and relevant, these risks are mitigated or controlled. The Executive Board and the Supervisory Board are responsible for risk management and the internal control systems in Royal Agrifirm Group.
In general, we have a low risk appetite with respect to significant business risks. A risks significance is determined by the likelihood of it occurring and its potential impact on our strategic objectives and financial targets.
An overview of the most important risks for realising the strategy and measures taken to control these risks, if feasible from a cost perspective, is given below.
Strategic risks
We have to make significant investments in order to reach our strategic targets. The risk appetite regarding these investments is low. Possible risks related to further growth and acquisitions are controlled through a strategic plan and targets related to growth and financing. As a result of the control measures, we are able to reduce the impact of a potential risk when it occurs to an acceptable level. Therefore the financial consequences are expected to be limited.
Operational risks
The main operational risks are related to the volatility of commodity prices, quality of raw materials and liquidity of customers. Due to the international spread of our activities, managing these risks is very important.
There is some risk appetite related to volatility of commodity prices, while the preparedness to accept risks related to the quality of raw materials is low. Volatility of commodity prices and a mismatch between purchase- and selling positions are being controlled by monitoring positions and continuous attention for cost efficiency. Additionally, to control this risk, guidelines are defined to set boundaries if and when a certain position has to be taken.
Animal diseases may have an adverse effect on the number of animals and additional costs for transportation. By securing the quality of raw materials, providing information to livestock farmers, geographical spread of the activities and the availability of contingency plans, which are tested regularly, we limit our risk.
The impact when a potential risk related to this subject occurs, is expected to be manageable for us due to the control measures taken. The continuous changes in the global markets, requires us to monitor and measure the risks constantly. Therefore, the process of risk management is implemented as an integrated part of our business processes. As a result financial consequences can be maintained to an acceptable low level.
Volatility of the financial performance of our customers, because of strong fluctuations of prices for their products, necessary investments and changes in law and regulations, may results in pressure on the liquidity of customers and increasing payment risks. Therefore, tight debtor management is an important part in every business department. Customers will be reviewed on different criteria before delivering. Where necessary and possible, additional securities will be formalized. Even more, risks will be ensured. Open balances will be monitored permanently. When the payment risks increase, the customer will be contacted in an early stadium to limit the risks as much as possible.
Financial risks
Financial risks are partly inherent to the strategic targets. Risk appetite of these risks is varying per type of risk. The appetite to accept interest risks is in principle low. As regards to currency risks, these will be evaluated per type of currency risk.
In 2015 we entered into a new credit facility. Several scenarios were made to determine the necessary funding. A ‘multi-currency revolving credit facility’ amounting to € 250 million was obtained for a period of at least five years. This covers the liquidity risk sufficiently.
Liquidity, interest and currency risks are being hedged by means of interest swaps and currency forward contracts and periodic liquidity planning. These treasury activities are predominantly taking place at Royal Agrifirm Group level.
The current geopolitical developments and the volatility of the global economy, made it very difficult to estimate exactly the possible impact these risks could have. Currency exposures did have a significant impact on translation of results of operating companies located in countries with a currency other than the euro. We are constantly alert in order to minimize the impact.
Compliance risks
The acceptation of risks that there is a situation of non-compliance with applicable laws and regulations, is very low. This is controlled by adopting an internal compliance code, ‘horizontaal toezicht’ and internal control procedures. This reduces the chance that non-compliance with applicable laws and regulations will occur.
Risk management measures
In designing and evaluating the structure of our risk management and control systems, the internationally acknowledged COSO framework for internal control is used as a frame of reference. This has been expanded in our Corporate Guidelines, which also covers a joint, risk-based framework of internal controls.
Within Royal Agrifirm Group this is an on-going process of identifying, analysing, validating, monitoring and evaluating significant risk areas and the controls in place, and of communicating and reporting about such process with the help of a risk register which enable the group companies to report about their risks, classifications and mitigating measures. The risk management model is used by all group companies of Royal Agrifirm Group. The first responsibility for the internal control system lies with the management of our companies. The model provides management of our companies with tools to identify, classify and control risks, and to report them to the Executive Board in an unambiguous way. During 2015 the risk registers were developed further resulting in more uniformity in classification of risks, clearer links to the hard and soft controls and better sharing of best practices between the our companies. Yearly, the risks registers are subject to discussions between the Executive Board and management of the group companies. Progress on mitigating risks is an integral part of the management reports. Additionally, the progress and the top risks are shared with the Supervisory Board.
We have the following guidelines, procedures, systems and organisational measures in place for controlling our business processes as well:
- Ethical business code of conduct.
- Whistleblower scheme.
- Systems for operational and financial planning, such as setting budgets and other operational and financial targets.
- Guidelines and procedures for the format and drafting of management reports and financial reporting.
- Periodic review of the achievement of set targets based on pre-defined critical success factors for all operational and functional disciplines.
- Guidelines and procedures for financing activities and controlling currency, interest rate risks and fixed-term deposits.
- Guidelines for the continuity and reliability of electronic data processing.
- Guidelines for the management of production processes and quality controls based on internationally recognised and certified methodologies and aligned with the applicable laws and regulations in the countries in which Royal Agrifirm Group operates.
- A quality assurance system for raw materials.
- Guidelines for internal control and monitoring, including authorisation procedures and segregation of duties.
- Letters of representation for Royal Agrifirm Group companies.
- Internal audit function.
The complete set of the controls listed above ensures that reasonable assurance is obtained that strategic and operational objectives are achieved, that the company’s (financial) reporting is reliable and that relevant laws and rules are complied with.
In 2016, as part of their assignment to audit our annual financial statements, the external auditor performed independent audits in order to check to what extent the system of internal control and administrative organisation were adequate. These audits were performed according to a program set up in consultation with the audit committee of the Supervisory Board. The information thus collected is used to make improvements to the internal risk management and control systems.
Royal Agrifirm Group and the Dutch Tax authorities signed the covenant ‘horizontaal toezicht’ for the fiscal unity of 'Koninklijke Coöperatie Agrifirm U.A.' In this covenant the framework is laid down how the Tax authorities and Royal Agrifirm Group cooperate in order to work effectively and efficiently together. Important condition to be able to apply for this covenant is to show the quality of the internal control processes related to taxes. The Tax authorities reviewed these processes and existing discussion points with the Tax authorities were solved.
Despite with how much care these systems and controls are designed, they do not provide absolute assurance that operational and financial corporate objectives will be achieved. Neither can all inaccuracies, errors or violations of laws and regulations be prevented using these systems.
Business planning and review
Our company pursues a system of budgeting and planning using standard procedures and detailed guidelines. With the management boards of our subsidiaries the Executive Board regularly reviews the achievement of strategic and operational objectives. Based on periodic financial and operational reports, the annual budgeting cycle and risk analysis. The risk monitoring results are reviewed. The risk management model consequently forms an integral part of Royal Agrifirm Groups business planning and budgeting control cycle.
Management statement
The Executive Board is responsible for managing the risks associated with the company’s objectives and the reliability of the internal and external financial and other reports. We base our internal control structure on the principle that management of our subsidiaries bear the primary responsibility for the day-to-day performance, compliance and monitoring of the systems that have been put in place to manage the key operational risks, to which our subsidiaries are exposed, as well as possible.
With respect to the limitations that are inevitably inherent to any risk management and internal control system, our internal risk management and control systems provide reasonable assurance that our financial reports are free of material misstatement and that these systems were adequate and effective in 2016.
The phrase ‘reasonable assurance’ has been used for the level of assurance that would be provided by a director acting with due care under the given circumstances. The set of procedures involving the internal risk management and control systems, and the related findings, recommendations and measures have been discussed with the audit committee, the Supervisory Board and the external auditor.